No, it does not appear to be our hosts intention. While I wish it were different, I can accept the decision and it won't bother me. My feeling is that SOME people might think twice before making a rude post. I don't buy the arguement that it would restrict discussion, most sites that I visit have similar arrangements and it works quite well.

Again, it really doesn't bother me either way, but if I had a preference and a vote (which I don't), I would opt for members only.