Imo, this issue is beyond the individual named Shambles.

It seems to me that the central issue is the fairness of Mudcat forum rules across the board and how fairly those rules are enforced.

It has been articulated that individual moderators have favorites. It has also been articulated that some individual moderators sometimes unfairly target those they do not favor.

Whether this is true or not, I hope that Max will address these questions by putting in place protections to guard against this happening.