Any other hints, like when it was aired (a decade would be good, a range of years would be better, a year would be best), and where in Ohio. Even if it's a city rather than a particular station, this can narrow down things. Was the show humorous (e.g. Big John & Li'l Chuck), or something more along the lines of the Twilight Zone? Do you remember if the show seemed to be for children (intro to a fantasy/story hour) or adults? If you saw the show more than once, did this scene happen in more than one show?