I assume PRS member is a songwriter. It's hard enough for songwriters to get gigs at trad clubs and festivals without appearing to hold contoversial views. A lot of organisers read mudcat. PRS member has always chosen his or her words carefully, yet has still been completely misunderstood a number of times in this debate. Its very easy for people reading a forum to get completely the wrong end of the stick even when one is not being controversial. I think he or she was well advised to remain incognito. Furthermore, his or her band might not appreciate being assocated with even a mere devil's advocate - perhaps they also have mortgages.

It matters not who put the motion - this thread has proved that debate is neccesary.

Time will take care of the outcome.