The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #96323   Message #1882906
Posted By: Sandra in Sydney
11-Nov-06 - 03:17 AM
Thread Name: Gender issue in singing
Subject: RE: Gender issue in singing
'He fades away' written & sung by Alistair Hulett is perfect sung by Alistair, or Miguel Heatwole - even tho the words are the lament of a woman watching her dying husband.

Conversely, John Dengate's 'Lanes of Wooloomooloo' a poem about a homeless alcoholic old soldier is magic when John recites it, but was totally wrong when a soprano put it to music. Perhaps it might have been better sung by a deeper female voice, but ...

sandra