Hymns Ancient and Modern was originally published in 1861 with a more successful edition published in 1875. It has just these Christmas Hymns

55 O come, Redeemer of mankind, appear
56 Of the Father's love begotten
57 O Christ, Redeemer of our race
58 God from on high hath heard
59 O come, all ye faithful
60 Hark, the herald angels sing
61 Christians, awake! salute the happy morn
62 While shepherds watched their flocks by night
63 O Saviour, Lord, to thee we pray

This was later supplemented by the Oxford Book of Carols - published in 1928, which would often be used by the choir, but not usually by the congregation.