I agree that the Bonhomme Richard was a makeshift warship not up to the standard of the Serapis which was a new 44gun ship - a two-decker fifth rate. The heavier broadside proved effective in sinking the Bonhomme Richard. The difference was in the crews, and it was the American crew that carried the day by boarding.

Possibly the difference was the actions of Alliance firing into both ships (perhaps contributing the Bonhomme Richard's sinking?). But Pearson would have only knew about the damage being caused to his own ship, the casualties he had taken and the fact that there was at least one strong, relatively fresh enemy ship in the offing.

I am unsure about the fact that Jones was possibly wanted for murder in the UK (I believe in quelling a mutiny) might have given him extra incentive. Any thoughts, evidence?

Les