I subscribe to Footstompin, which works because it has a lot of people on it knowledgeable about Scottish music. But it has a lot of problems:

- a culture of anonymity even worse than this place (what the fuck are you all afraid of, not signing your posts with your real names?);

- a somewhat prissy policy of censorship which goes far beyond the commercial requirements of the site;

- a few posters whose self-indulgence screams "censor me" loudly enough to make the average reader want to hand the whole shebang over to the Taleban;

- a plague of Celtic-wannabe American dickheads wanting translations of Engliush mottoes into Gaelic, which leads to deadly spiral as more and more of those requests are indexed by Google thereby sending more and more of the morons to Footstompin;

- technical support people who neither fix problems nor respond to bug reports and don't even acknowledge who they are.