So Max can tell Shambles that he is being asked to leave but then does nothing about making sure that he leaves but Guests who may have something worthwhile to say but don't feel like using a name won't be allowed to post.

That makes sense. Leave the posting to those who complain and insult management but edit supporters of the site who don't want to assume a fake identity.

---

The Shambles complaint messages have been more-or-less confined to one thread at a time for several months now. Most posts of GUESTS who refuse to use a name are now being deleted, whether the posts are harmful or innocuous. If you don't want to be deleted, all you have to do is use a consistent name.
-Joe Offer-