Dorothy Shay's performance of SAGEBRUSH SADIE appears on the album "Here's Dorothy Shay," Sepia Recordings CD #1078, 2006. Here's what I was able to piece together from a couple of sound samples:
... on the Hit Parade In a manner that we never did expect.
Unlike any of her kin, She grew whiskers on her chin And her sideburns caused the neighbors to remark. [unintelligible – doesn't sound like English] Soon her beard became full-grown And they've got her on display in Central Park.
They call her Sagebrush Sadie The famous bearded lady. Her whiskers brought her riches and renown. They're the pride of the museum And it costs two bits to see 'em And the family's getting rich on Sadie Brown.
All the neighbors thereabout Tried their best to figure out Why she grew a set of whiskers but they can't. Both her sisters look like Ma, And the boys resemble Pa, But Sadie seems to favor General Grant.