The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #95631   Message #1958163
Posted By: Murray MacLeod
05-Feb-07 - 03:07 PM
Thread Name: YouTube Folkmusic Video PermaThread
Subject: RE: YouTube Folkmusic Video PermaThread
Shaneo, I am not denying Diedre's ability as a singer, but do you think her rendition of this song belongs in this symposium ?

I would say she belongs to the Daniel O'Donnell, Foster and Allen, and Dana school of Irish singing, "good" singers all of them , but imo they don't belong in here alongside Paul Brady and Andy Irvine.