The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #99658   Message #1989021
Posted By: GUEST,Gerry
06-Mar-07 - 10:23 PM
Thread Name: Origins:Songs based on non-classical instrumentals
Subject: RE: Origins: Songs based on non-classical instrmentls
The Yiddish ballad Papirosn consists of lyrics set to a pre-existing tune.
I think the same may be true for Ale Brider because I've heard a different set of words sung to the same tune (Bay Mayn Rebbe Iz Gevezen a Ganeyva, or something like that). I've also heard a song, Liebe Tochter, to the tune of Tanz, Tanz, Yiddelekh, and I'm pretty sure the tune came first.