I think it's a silly hypothesis. But who I would choose would depend very much on how long I had to be there. In the short term I'd enlist people like Kendall and Rapaire and even Claymore. (I would definitely NOT choose The Terrible T- a desk warrior is not of great use.)

For the long haul I would in addition choose other people, people who would entertain me, make me think, help me put my dilemma into perspective. Some of those would be women, some would not.