We were talking the other day of the oral tradition and the idea that by the simple act of recording, by whatever media, the oral tradition ceases. My daughter came up with the best idea I have heard in a long time. Because the past IS important and because, without records, knowing how people did things in the part is impossible, we should indeed record folk music (Whatever that is!). However once it is recorded the record should then be removed from all public domain and be placed under lock and key so that only historians and those interested in what used to happen can see or hear it. Anyone saying this is how it was, is and always should be needs to be locked away with it:-)

I would agree with the premise of the thread title but qualify it somewhat. Publication does a doubtful service to music - But only when those who insist that adherance to the publication is the only way gain control!

Cheers

Dave