The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #104457   Message #2139453
Posted By: Rumncoke
03-Sep-07 - 04:45 AM
Thread Name: She changed the words to Raglan Road
Subject: RE: She changed the words to Raglan Road
I don't know the song - but I do know that some women feel awkward or even embarassed singing a song written from the male perspective, and feel that they ought to alter the gender to be appropriate, or not sing the song at all.

I have tried to argue that the audience is not going to take offence at any song sung by a person apparently of another sex from the original narrator, but to little effect.

To alter the words for one effect is bad enough - but to then go on to alter the song's content is worse. I don't mind a good parody or total send up, particularly when a song deserves it - but to have a not quite original is neither one thing nor the other.