Tom Iagree.
Jim Carroll,you are an amateur collector[itwas not your livelihood],I dont know what your job was, but you expected to get paid for it.
Anne had her own compositions[we are not talking about traditional music ]used without her permission,they are her property,she has to give permission first,that is the law.
composed music differs from traditional music,however composed arrangements are also copyrighted[MartinCarthys guitar arrangement of Scarborough Fair],that means the song[but not his arrangement is available ,the arrangement must have his his permission,it was his creative work] that is the law.