Cap'n, Stop trying to score points - it doesn't become you - or on second thoughts......... I was responding to a previous question. All threads creep, especially ones about acquisitive and possessive people trying to market songs that have been freely shared in the past, particularly traditional ones, (as a singer, you have been the beneficiary of having the songs passed on to you without payment, just like the rest of us). Jim Carroll PS you are right about one thing; I am entitled to my opinion, in spite of having been told on numerous occasions that I am not, because I no longer sing - but I think we've seen the back of that one, don't you?