The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #104774   Message #2149353
Posted By: Greg B
14-Sep-07 - 03:04 PM
Thread Name: Fretted Fiddles
Subject: RE: Fretted Fiddles
It seems to me that the argument that it will help beginners
learn correct intonation (so that they can subsequently go on
to get rid of the 'training wheels') doesn't quite work.

When you play a fretted instrument, you press down on the string
behind, not on, the fret. You can do this rather sloppily
as well, so long as you mash the string down.

Without frets, you press very precisely and consistently at the
precise point on the fingerboard which produces the desired tone.
If you're at the wrong place--- wrong tone. If you aren't square
or fret in any kind of soft fashion you can dull the sound.

For me, moving from a fretted to a fretless banjo wasn't just a
matter of putting my fingers where I always did--- I had to adjust
the position a bit. And I had to learn to hear the intonation
in order to learn what was correct.

That, to me, seems to be the key thing--- hearing the intonation.
The fiddle frets might help with that, but at the expense of training
the fingers to go down further towards the peg-head than they're
supposed to and to be rather imprecise besides. So the student
trained with frets may know he or she sounds like hell without
them, but may have quite a learning curve to gain back what is
lost, what with retraining all those brain cells and nerves to
do something very different without the frets.

P.S.: What about vibrato?