The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #106404 Message #2199362
Posted By: PoppaGator
21-Nov-07 - 02:26 PM
Thread Name: Duane Allman's - Little Martha
Subject: RE: Duane Allman's - Little Martha
"Open D" (major) and "Open E" tunings are really the same, relatively speaking, and the old bluesmen recognized that fact by calling it "Vastapol tuning" regardless of absolute pitch (after a well-known tune played exclusively in that tuning).
To retune from standard to open-D, three strings are lowered in pitch (loosened); to change from standard turing to open-E, the other three strings have to be raised (tightened).
Acoustic players generally prefer the open-D version of Vastapol, preumably because tuning up to open-E often results in prematurely broken strings.
The extra-light strings customarily used on electric guitars seem better able to stretch without snapping, so electric players are somewhat more prone to tune up to open-E.
Another reason to opt for the open-E alternative is that the key of E is far preferable to D when playing blues on the guitar in standard tuning. For a slide-blues player in a band (or even a duo) with one or more standard-tuned guitars, use of open-E tuning is pretty much universal.
As Jed observes, you can tune to open-D and capo up two frets to play in E, but simply tuning to open-E in the first place is easier and, for light-strung electric guitars, not a problem. I'm almost certain that Duane Allman used open-E very regularly.