So, has anyone actually read this book? I think it's interesting that so many people are denouncing a book they haven't read. Shouldn't we suspend judgment until we read the damn thing? From the reviews, I thought the book probably had something worthwhile to say about the way an urban myth can be perpetuated until it becomes the "truth" that informs subsequent attitudes and decisions. But I, too, am suspending judgment until I read it myself.

I am fortunate enough to be an veteran of eight years of service in the peacetime American military. I have enormous respect for the sacrifices of those who fought for the United States. I think the Vietnam war was unjust and based on some seriously flawed assumptions, but that is no reflection on the people who actually fought on our side of that war -- whether they were there by choice or were compelled by the government to serve. By and large these were dedicated, honorable people who deserve our respect and gratitude.