Good enough Mick. If I had to define the characteristics of a good pub in Ireland, that would be about it. I guess I'm a bit skeptical about trying to recreate something like an Irish pub anywhere else. I've seen so many pale imitations, and too many trying much too hard.
My local in England doesn't try to be Irish at all; but the landlord used to live in Templemore, and the pub you describe sounds a lot like his. It's not about decor, or a 'theme'. It's about the people, and the community that builds up around a good pub. Good music doesn't hurt either, especially when it's encouraged.
Very best.
Tim