Joe, got your Personal Msg. I would suggest limiting any Classic Threads list to 10 at most. As in all "Best Of" lists, the matter is certainly open to dispute and conjecture. I would think that Classic Threads should give new Mudcatters an idea of the scope of discussion, the Sublime to the Slightly Silly. The Spancil Hill Thread should certainly be there, but probably the Tiple Thread as well. How would these threads be selected? By popular Mudcat acclaim, or by the Special Appointment of Max? I may start a separate thread to get Catters feeling on the Mudcat Classic Threads concept.