"Ted the tenor, and George the baritone singing from the same hymn sheet...and you're looking at the SAME! top-line melody (in A! given key) and listening to the same organ as you do so - you are NOT, thus, singing in different keys/you are singing the same top-line with naturally different (sop., tenor, baritone) God-given voices, yes?"

If I wasn't aware already (which I was), this finally settles it, WAV doesn't know what he's talking about. I'm printing this out and will show it to my voice teacher in the morning.

Charlotte R