The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #49087   Message #2342651
Posted By: Barry Finn
17-May-08 - 01:39 AM
Thread Name: Sea music CD, Time Ashore is Over-radriano
Subject: RE: New sea music CD, Time Ashore is Over
If it's "COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL" does that mean it can ONLY be sung the way it was written? Is that how folk music now works & gets passed on? If so, it sounds to me as if it's dead in the water before it gets a chance to sink or swim.

Can or should artistic control be carried this far?
I know it sounds as if it was an oversight by the singer & there was an apology made but is it that important that the author should demand that it can & should be sung only that way & that is the only "right" way to sing it? Was not the original idea of copyright's intent to try to enhance the artistic flow & cause the public's creative juices to grow. Sounds more like a song in chains to me, sorry.

I have this CD & IMHO I couldn't care less if a word was changed in error, I'd be dam pleased, hearing the job they did with all the songs on this, if they had covered anything I wrote. Maybe next CD you guys will consider covering one of my songs. Do you pay royalities too, to boot? He,He,He!

Barry