The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #111448   Message #2347385
Posted By: CarolC
23-May-08 - 12:43 AM
Thread Name: BS: effective arguments
Subject: RE: BS: effective arguments
Saying that an author lacks the authority to write about a topic is a variant of ad hominem—and a particularly useless sort, because good ideas often come from outsiders. The question is whether the author is correct or not. If his lack of authority caused him to make mistakes, point those out. And if it didn't, it's not a problem.

I love this part. This one gets used quite a lot in some discussions, like, for instance, discussions about 9/11.