The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #73142   Message #2352208
Posted By: Jon Bartlett
29-May-08 - 02:17 PM
Thread Name: lyr/chords: Farewell Johnny Miner (Ed Pickford)
Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Farewell Johnny Miner (Ed Pickford)
Ah, the oral tradition. I sing the lines as:

1.2 Never to see the rising sun
3.1 You've battled hard with slate and shale

What I heard sounded very muddled and so I became a Rationalizer (is that the right term?). My thinking for 1.2: the dawn doesn't rise, the sun does.
And for 3.1 what I heard (can't remember now what it was) made no sense at all.

Now here's a question, mudcatters: should I now revert (courtesy of the DT) to the "correct" words or should I continue in my errant ways?

Jon Bartlett