Resident singers who are disciplined

And does everyone else get to take it in turns doing the disciplining? I have a whip in my valise...

Only joking.

I'll come back in a bit with construcive comments, and I promise they will be constructive... however I must indulge myself in my new policy of reflecting on my comments before rarther than after posting them. So for now I'll join Betsy in the formulation suite.

I also think it would be useful for people like Paul who run a club widely acknowedged as a good example of how to do it right to tell us what they think they're currently doing that's right.