"there's nothing in the least bit traditional about chromaticism" (IB)and I never said there was; I said, rather, that I enjoy playing the tenor recorder (brought back as a student, folk, as well as early music, instrument, early last century, mainly by English and Germans - we now have both English and German fingering), and listening to others play the penny whistle. (My total repertoire now invloves 6/7 keys - I only transpose when the score goes below middle C - the tenor's lowest note.)