The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #112725 Message #2389038
Posted By: peregrina
14-Jul-08 - 05:47 PM
Thread Name: BS: Why not just BAN Guests?
Subject: RE: happy wayfaring stranger
My mudcat name means foreigner or traveller. I have spent my adult life living in working in countries where I am not a citizen, sometimes for years, sometimes just months or weeks.
I have often been deeply deeply touched by kindness and hospitality when I moved to a new place. People who extended open-hearted offers of friendship, or just strangers helping a stranger whose luggage was unmanageable. I had it easy with work permits, but in one country I befriended refugees and had a tiny glimpse of what it might mean to leave everything behind and then face unimaginable struggle. I have had people yell rude things because of my nationality, or extend a welcome because they thought I was related to their country.
Welcome and kindness offered and accepted just because the other person is a human being are always the most precious.--I hope I have kept the great circle of this kindness going through small gestures, but my own hospitality can fail when I am threatened or fearful.
It's not an accident that hospitality is a high value in many religions across the world, and in certain regions, among desert people, Indians, too, when sharing and trust were a matter of survival.
I am deeply touched by kindness to strangers the same way I am deeply moved by some music. It's not so much that 'some have entertained angels unaware' or that Elijah needs a place (though that may be), but that openness and kindness are part of shared humanity, as opposed to the gang-clique us versus them mentality.--Our species started in Africa, we are a diasporic species and we are all guests and travellers on the planet.
Rules: a place where the laws are enforced selectively is a tyranny. Even-handedness and consistency would make this a more hospitable place.
I am point-blank horrified by the suggestion of banning guests and by guest-baiting: both bespeak a mob mentality. Disagree with ideological poison, yes, but then let it sink into silence.
A forum was the place where citizens could speak publicly. If guests or anonymous posters bring provocation, why answer? See how fast the thread can fall off the page.