The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #112909   Message #2394786
Posted By: GUEST,Marymac90
22-Jul-08 - 01:18 AM
Thread Name: Origins: Got a Mule & Her Name is Sal/Erie Canal?
Subject: RE: Origins: Got a Mule & Her Name is Sal/Erie Canal?
Well, Barry, I grew up in Syracuse, NY, and they did try
to teach us our local history, about the canal and all.
They did actually teach geography back in that era, too.

This Erie Canal song was in the school's song book, and
we learned it in our once-a-week music lessons. There
were two verses and one chorus, as best I can remember,
and I never thought twice about who wrote any song way
back then. None of the verses alluded to deceit,
aggression, drinking or sin, neither human nor mule.
No words even close to cusses, like "Darn", either.

Is it any wonder we couldn't wait to grow up? Not only
couldn't we read about the real world in Dick and Jane,
we couldn't sing about it, even in the "folk" songs we
were given to learn! Everything was whitewashed,
pureed to a pablum-like consistency, suitable for spoon-
feeding.

Sorry to turn your lyric request into my rant. It just
hit me where I live, or where I used to live, at least.

All the best,

Marymac