The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #114232   Message #2438300
Posted By: GUEST,Larry
12-Sep-08 - 09:37 AM
Thread Name: Hunting, poaching and whaling songs
Subject: RE: Hunting, poaching and whaling songs
Isn't the issue not what the songs say but the reason that you are singing them? I now hat sounds a bit social worker but bear with me!
The BNP story above is a case in point: once you know why they are being sung then you change your mind about singing them. If you are singing it because it is a good song, or it is evocative of a time past, or such like then IMHO that's okay. Perhaps when context changes so may judgement?