"You've convinced me. As of now, my two favorite examples of folk music are the Bach B Minor Mass and a chocolate eclair. "

With all due respect Dick, you are being ridiculous. We have had this discussion in person and whether you wish to admit it or not, you know that I am NOT saying that "everything is folk music", but you seem to want to put those words in my mouth.

Dick, I respect the work you have done and I respect EVERYONE that has preserved and perpetuate TRADITIONAL folk music. I don't buy the fears that people like Jim Carroll have expressed about these traditions being lost because of an interest in the folk music that is created by contemporary cultures and communtities.

These discussions are getting more absurd because no one wants to listen to what the other person is saying and people cling to their own stubborn beliefs. I am really sick and tired of all the narrow minded attitudes that will only acknowledge one or two particular styles - usually something that starts with a British tradition - and fails to acknowledge that other cultures in contemporary settings are doing EXACTLY the same things that their ancestors did - utilizing the tools and modes of communication that are available. These expressions are dealing with the same issues and serving the same purpose.

No one is saying that you need to enjoy rap music in order to earn your folkie stripes. Everyone is certainly entitled to listen to music that appeals to their senses and satisfies their needs. At the same time, there is something seriously wrong when the organic process that created an interest in "folk music" can no longer be acknowledged.