I don't read every thread on Mudcat, and was unaware of the other thread you've pointed out. I was making this exact point with the Youtube link i posted earlier, actually - if you have a look at it, Snail, you'll see that.

My last post was a response to WAV's most recent points, and I believe it was perfectly valid as an attack on the beliefs, rather than the person.


From experience, and FWIW, his threads do not simply disappear below the horizon; he continually resurrects them or starts new ones, and fills them with the same poisonous dogma.

While those who have posted here need to be conscious of their motives, WAV is as responsible as anyone for keeping these arguments alive.