Thanks again to everyone for the ongoing discussion. This reminds me of the best exchanges we've had on the 'cat. Of course I wish Fielding could put in his opinion.

I'm looking for a good teacher in my area, someone who can make a good evaluation of my friend's left hand, and help her make a good start. Any beginner needs a good teacher, right?

In the meantime, a good friend who is a hell of a player (known to many of you) has offered to put one of his guitars in her hands to see what's possible.

I'll keep you posted.

Thanks again,

D