The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #116474   Message #2527252
Posted By: s&r
30-Dec-08 - 06:16 AM
Thread Name: The Weekly Walkabout cum Talkabout
Subject: RE: The Weekly Walkabout cum Talkabout
Oh Dear WAV

It's hard to know where to start:

I don't like the tone of most of your posts. They convey most of the attributes that I would wish did not exist in the world.
But I think you think you are a nice guy.
Your posts are badly written and argued: they have been refuted repeatedly by wiser people than I.
But I think you think you have achieved some wisdom.
Your poetry is not very good.
But I think you are proud of your life's work.
Your music is execrable and your musical knowledge limited by your blinkered views and lack of research.
But I think you think you are knowledgeable.

I haven't criticized you as a person (or at any rate not much).
But I have criticized your banal and unfounded postings.

Your claim that I ignore the argument is of course unfounded as are most of your wild defences. Arguments and discussions in educated circles follow a set of conventions, where a concept is presented, with some evidence: this is then discussed rationally and systematically, by pros and cons with further evidence as appropriate.

But I think that you think you argue rationally.

This is probably why I and others try to improve your education

Regards

Stu