The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #118853   Message #2573844
Posted By: CarolC
23-Feb-09 - 12:02 PM
Thread Name: BS: Obama and Torture
Subject: RE: BS: Obama and Torture
According to the All Party Parliamentary Group on Extraordinary Rendition (House of Commons), in the first UK link above, what the lawyer said is fact...

"British court asks that President Obama
reconsider his predecessor's repeated "threats"
levelled against the judges who considered allowing
the public to learn the details of American torture of Binyam Mohamed

In an extraordinary ruling, two British judges sitting on the case of Binyam Mohamed have revealed how the US government has "threatened" the British government with reprisals should the British reveal evidence that American agents were involved in his rendition and torture. The judges end the decision with a plea to President Obama to reconsider President Bush's remarkable policy of retribution against anyone who might reveal American crimes:

If the information in the redacted paragraphs which we consider so important to the rule of law, free speech and democratic accountability is to be put into the public domain, it must now be for the United States Government to consider changing its position or itself putting that information into the public domain.

Mohamed v. Secretary of State, at ¶107.

No fewer than eight times, the judges refer to the American "threat" made against their closest ally, the British. Mohamed v. Secretary of State, at ¶¶62, 70, 73, 76, 76, 76, 77, 107). The British intelligence services have 42 documents that apparently demonstrate abuse of Binyam Mohamed a British resident."


However, it might all be moot in the not to distant future, since they're saying that Mohamed is very close to death at this point.