The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #118899   Message #2575966
Posted By: Austin P
25-Feb-09 - 06:25 PM
Thread Name: Test your Musical Ear
Subject: RE: Test your Musical Ear
90%; second time 70%. What a laugh. What the hell are they testing?

The fact is, they all sound different for the simple reason they are generated using different tonal envelopes. This is why banjo players don't play guitars.

Give us a test using the same instrument. Or a clean tone generator, not midi. What is the control strategy of this so called 'scientific test' I wonder?*

The site doesn't work properly under Firefox anyway - and why target Folk Musicians?

Harrumph. "Bloody Piano Tuners" (c) AL Lloyd

AP

*Double-Blind drunk would be appropriate I think ;O)