The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #119179   Message #2585634
Posted By: Jim Carroll
10-Mar-09 - 11:24 AM
Thread Name: Performance Ability does it matter?
Subject: RE: Performance Ability does it matter?
Sinister:
I had no idea I had commented on your singing - doesn't mean I wouldn't have if I had known - sing in public and you should expect comments - doesn't mean you have to agree with them.
For me, any interpretation of a song has to arise from its narrative; I got no such interpretation from any of the clips.
Bryan:
My statement was aimed at the comment that all that was needed to sing in public was the desire to do so - nothing else. It is your statement that I believe promotes bad standards; I have no idea how you put it into practice
You later went on to say that you don't get bad singers turning up to sing at your club and appeared to use that as an argument that they were a figment of our imagination, contrary to what others have said (including the person who started that particular thread)
Aren't there any bad wannabes in Sussex; have you scared them all off - tell us the secret of your success and make these threads redundant.
Jim Carroll