So sad!

I only ever met him via his postings on Mudcat but his scholarship set, for me anyway, the benchmark. Always succinct, only ever critical in the properly constructive sense, his contributions will be sorely missed.

Because of the detail he contributed and also the way he drew together the relevant postings from diverse threads I think it important that newcomers have their attention drawn to his contributions. Perhaps via a Permathread. Some may see this as a memorial but I suggest it as a valuable resource.

Vale Malcolm!