As has been said elsewhere in this thread, it is a matter of taste and for my money the "accompanist" should be just that, augmenting and aiding the melody instruments and providing a solid rhythmic base.
I agree,but I was trying to give you an example quickly,I stated my preference, which was for a partial sub,but there are loads of other occassions when I have heard it used successfully.
Vic,I dont care what you like.I have heard PaulDeGrae,he is a fabulous sensitive accompanist.I havent heard you,but do you get asked to accompany Jackie Daly?