Ridiculous is an understatement. If you were talking about most INFLUENTAL songwriter, a case could be made for Dylan (and George M Cohan, John Phillips Sousa, etc.)

BEST Songwriters? I'd bet a million bucks that the reviewer has never even heard of 3/4 of the songwriters that get mentioned on Mudcat. Unless you're a Beach Boy fan, you'd be hard pressed to name more than five or six Wilson songs.

Just silly and shows total ignorance. Now the KEY question is how many Star readers, would be able to name ten quality songwriters period? Very few I'll bet.

Rick