The cd Boxing Clever,which is a concertina compilation,and included John Kirkpatrick,TimLaycock, HarryScurfield, DickMiles,was reviewed in FolkRoots and received a good review.
I have never complained about any reviews.
Vic Smith would do better not to give his interpretation in personal messages,but would do better to let people have the original post.
MattMilton, VicSmith,Greg Stephens are all members of Froots and very regular contributors/posters to the board.