This reminds me of Stick Quiz. It'splayed like this: One person gets to hold the stick, and asks each of the others a question. If they get it wrong, he gets to hit them with the stick.
Here's an example...
Stick man- "What number am I thinking of?"
Player- "Three?"
Stickman- "No". (whack)

This game is lots of fun if you have the stick, and is way simpler than You Don't Mean That.