".. but did the newcomer who didn't want to hear songs about dead animals come back after that?"

ummm...I don't believe so. She seemed bemused by our 'scope of interests', but I don't think she returned.

(To be fair, a lot of folks don't know what to expect, and it's not uncommon that we see them only once....usually because they ONLY know or care about 'pop-folk' from the 70's)