The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #121936   Message #2668192
Posted By: Jack Campin
30-Jun-09 - 02:34 PM
Thread Name: Bodhrain tuning.
Subject: RE: Bodhrain tuning.
Upmarket bodhrans do have tuners, like those on Turkish metal darbukas.

I'm not quite sure what bodhranists are aiming at when they retune. The sound they usually prefer is a dull thud - i.e. they detune enough that no definite pitch is perceptible, but leaving enough tension on the skin to get a reasonably loud sound. This is quite different from what most Middle Eastern frame drum players do - they either select the drum or tune it to get the highest, pingiest sound possible. This goes along with a different philosophy about what the drum is for. In a Middle Eastern band, it drives the whole ensemble; the drummer is effectively the conductor. (In Sufi music, the kettledrum has the central role, and is understood to be a metaphor for the creative energy of God). But bodhranists seem to want to produce such a vague, blurry sound that they could never take the lead and nobody listening could ever tell when they made a mistake. It's an aesthetic of timidity. What do they get out of this?