The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #122570   Message #2695556
Posted By: Taconicus
07-Aug-09 - 01:05 PM
Thread Name: Us and Them: folk music and political persuasion
Subject: RE: Us and Them: folk music and political persuasion
{{I question Taconius' knowledge of topical songs.People like Eric Bogle,John Mccutcheon, Fred Small, Judy Small, etc. have been writing songs subtle enough to make a point without upsetting anybody. The previously mentioned Tommy Makem's "Four Green Fields" was his best known song.Taconius, something tells me you're debating a subject about which you have very little first hand knowledge.If I'm mistaken, forgive me.}}

Well of course I forgive you, Elmore--except that there's nothing to forgive. I don't see anything in your post that argues with anything I've said, but it does make me wonder just what you think it is I'm "debating."

Moving on, I certainly agree with you that it's possible -- more than possible -- to make a political, moral, or ethical point without demonizing people. I like those songs, songs that make me think, even if I disagree with the singer on the topic. I don't think that's what the OP was talking about, and it's certainly not what I was talking about.

{{If this is not about censorship, what is it about?}}

Well it certainly seems to be what you're talking about, but if there was anyone in this thread advocating censorship of unpopular (or popular) political speech, I must've missed it.