The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #123224   Message #2711471
Posted By: Alan Day
29-Aug-09 - 09:43 AM
Thread Name: how can musical critics improve?
Subject: RE: how can musical critics improve?
I cannot understand why critics have to fault find when they review a CD or collection and then finish up with writing how enjoyable it was.If it was enjoyable and recommended for all to listen to, why not list the things that was liked about the CD and then the few dislikes.It is a much more honest approach and constructive for the musician (s) and the prospective purchaser of the CD, rather than a miserable slagging off without justification.
Al