The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #123555 Message #2721772
Posted By: Jim Carroll
11-Sep-09 - 02:38 PM
Thread Name: Why do we sing unaccompanied?
Subject: RE: Why do we sing unaccompanied?
The British tradition, with a tiny handful of exceptions, is an unnaccomanied one, because, I believe, it is a strictly narrative one. There is no reason whatever why accompaniment shouldn't be used for folk songs - as long as that is what it does - accompany. Too often the instrument is either too loud, so the words are lost to the listener, or too intrusive and distracts the attention. There is an argument (Netl, I think) that a combination of song and crude instrumentation (even the sound of the work itself) accompanied some work songs; believable if you listen to Lomax's recording of convicts chopping wood. Jim Carroll