Jim C: as a 'not quite newbie now' to this folk song lark (nearing a year) SO'P continues to remain one of the most interesting and indeed inspiring singers I've heard. And according to some of the young and more interesting folk bands I've (albeit briefly) brushed up against, he appears to go down rather well in fact. My deep suspicion is that that might be, because he's actually rather good at what he does...

As to "Who gives a toss?" Well, I think you do some of your fellow contributors a rather large disservice here. It's clear (and been stated as such) that members here at least, do give a toss! While a few might disagree with your view, they surely wouldn't be wasting otherwise profitable time debating such matters with you, if they *didn't care?*

You are clearly a deeply passionate and learned man in your subject. But you also tend to come across in a somewhat alienating *manner*. Some weeks ago I reviewed the old classic film 'Goodbye Mr. Chips', and I'm afraid to say, rather like the eponymous Chips, that your on-line personality could easily push possible younger enthusiasts away from even beginning to listen you out.

If you don't like the 'pop' that you hear (which IS encouraging new voices), I'd humbly suggest that you stop grumping about it and provide a substantial alternative for those young enthusiasts out there who will be more than interested in learning from solid resources. Get those Critics teaching materials online. It's never been a riper time. Carpe Diem!