The police check thing is quickly becoming a plague.

I agree that home schooling should be somehow registered and monitored but no way that should automatically require putting kids on the risk register.

I also agree that youth workers, paid or unpaid, should have some level of check, but that should not be draconian, difficult to undertake, or expensive.

My current problem is organizing a 3 day music 'camp'. I'd like it to be intergenerational. Heck - our National Assembly even has a 'policy' to encourage intergenerational, community activity. I can't offer it, though. Yes, I can check the tutors and workers BUT apparently the Powers That Be are also suggesting I have to check everyone on the course who is over 16 years old. Honest. They've also tried to take this line with the National Youth Choir, Orchestra, Brass Band, Wind Band, etc. When pushed by their organizers, the Children's Commissioner has gone quiet, but not withdrawn the opinion.

I really think we have to challenge this, sooner rather than later. What are we telling young people? That a) everyone over 16 is potentially a pervert so don't trust ANYONE and b) that when they turn 17 they too will be a potential pervert.

We're also always told that a high percentage of child abuse is inflicted by close family or friends so how does this legislation help? Other high profile cases would never have happened if the existing law had been properly applied; stacking up laws upon laws won't solve any problems if the real problem is resources to enforce the basics.

The government is moving us towards full-blown identity cards with every aspect of our lives needing specific approval. Possibly even full checks before you can even be parents? There was a time when ID cards didn't worry me too much, but I understand the protest now.

sian